Good Words

Sermon 07/02/2006

A City Built on a Hill ~ by Reverand Thomas Cary Kinder
July 2, 2006 Fourth Sunday after Pentecost, Independence Day Sunday
First Congregational Church in Thetford, Vermont, UCC
Psalm 130; Acts 2:43-47; II Corinthians 8:7-15; Matthew 5:1-16


This week a Valley News front-page headline read, “Thetford Residents at Odds Over Flying the Flag.” The controversy arose over a request by the Thetford Center Community Association to fly several American flags on utility poles continuously from Memorial Day to Columbus Day every year.

People feel strongly on all sides of this issue. The Select Board came up with a compromise—the flags will be up from Memorial Day through the Fourth of July, and then for other special holidays as well. That does not change the way people will feel about the flags. Some will have a warm and proud feeling about America when they see them. Some will be reminded of their fear of terrorist who threaten America, or gratitude and fear for people they love who are fighting in American wars overseas. Some will feel shame for America’s actions. Some will feel uncomfortable, afraid that the flying of the flags is making a statement of support for national policies that they oppose—including the very military actions that make others want to fly the flags. Some will feel a mix of these and other feelings, but few, I suspect, will pass by the flags without some emotions welling up in them.

This is good. This is fitting if you look at if from the point of view of the gospels. Jesus said in the Sermon on the Mount, “You are the light of the world. A city built on a hill cannot be hid. No one after lighting a lamp puts it under a bushel basket, but on a lampstand, and it gives light to all in the house. In the same way, let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to God.” Later in the Sermon on the Mount he warned us, “If the light in you is darkness, how great is that darkness!”

Jesus calls us to create a society that is a light to the world, a city built on a hill that will stand as a model of what is good. Puritans who came to this land to create a new society came with just that ideal. John Winthrop said aboard the Arbella in 1630, “For we must consider that we shall be as a city built on a hill; the eyes of all people are upon us.”

So it is good to see the flag and observe our feelings and be reminded of how well we are fulfilling Christ’s calling to let the light of our good works shine to the world for the glory of God. It is good to be forced to reflect on whether our nation’s light is purely the light of Christ-like charitable lovingkindness and humble self-sacrifice, or if it is to some extent the darkness of selfish greed and arrogant pride.

Freedom of religion is essential to America’s founding vision. We should never have any religion imposed on us by the state. Religion does have an essential role in America, though, and that is to guide our moral and ethical judgment, and to help us measure how well our state is living up to our highest ideals as articulated by our religion.

Religion also leads us to the power that the Psalm was talking about today. “With God is great power to redeem: It is God who will redeem Israel from its iniquities.” It is God who can redeem America from all its flaws—Gods higher power that is greater than the most corrupt corporate lobby in Washington; God’s higher power that is greater that the unimaginably vast military-industrial complex; God’s higher power that is greater than the political organization of the religious right. God’s power will redeem us.

That force flows according to its own laws. The sacred way is not the way of human pride or greed. We glimpse the society the Holy Spirit wants to create when we read about some of those very early churches that were so close to Christ. The Book of Acts tells about the first church’s wonders and signs, its healings and beautiful words and most of all, its selfless, generous sharing of goods with all who were in need. All we have comes from God, they believed, and should be used to serve others so that the Creation can become full of the mercy and lovingkindness of God.

The Apostle Paul expressed the same principles twenty years later. He wrote, “I do not mean that there should be relief for others and pressure on you, but it is a question of fair balance between your present abundance and their need,” or their abundance and your need. Paul pointed to the way God distributed the manna in the wilderness, the one time since the Garden of Eden when God stepped in and ordered the human economy. As Paul says, God saw to it that, “The one who had much did not have too much, and the one who had little did not have too little.”

These are among the most important principles of our religion. How are we doing at creating a society in that image? When people look at the church is that what they see? When people around the world look at the American flag, when they look to us as a city built on a hill, do they see the light of these principles—of generous, selfless sharing with all who are in need, making sure that the rich are not too rich and the poor are not too poor? Or do they see a great darkness of selfishness and greed, the rich getting richer while the poor get poorer, the darkness of not caring what others suffer as long as we get what we want? Certainly there is both darkness and light in America. In the struggle between the two, which seems to be dominating and increasing?

There may be no more important document to guide a society that wants to be virtuous than the Sermon on the Mount, beginning with the Beatitudes. A nation that treats the poor in spirit as blessed is a nation that has already become part of the kingdom of heaven. A nation that values highly the meek will inherit the earth because it will not have the arrogance to destroy it. A nation that hungers and thirst for doing what is right will be filled, whereas a culture obsessed with filling its gluttonous appetites will always feel empty. A merciful nation will receive mercy, but a society that hates its enemies and pursues vengeance and does not care how many innocent people it kills or impoverishes along the way, a nation that tortures and imprisons illegally—such a society will receive no mercy when its day of reckoning comes, unless there is a society in the world that more faithfully practices the mercy Jesus preached. Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God, but whose children are the people who fail to do what makes for peace—who fail to be so selfless and generous and merciful that peace spreads across the world wherever their light shines?


The Russian novelist Fyodor Dostoevsky wrote in the voice of a wise Christian elder named Zosima in the book The Brothers Karamazov. Zosima taught that anytime we see another person’s sin we should consider ourselves to blame, because if we ourselves were truly good, if we shined a pure light, we might have influenced that person not to sin. Zosima also said that when we stand before a great wrong we will wonder whether to respond with force or with love. He said, always respond with humble love. He said, “If you so resolve once and for all, you will be able to overcome the whole world. A loving humility is a terrible power, the most powerful of all, nothing compares with it.” (p319, Vintage 1991 edition)

There are genocides happening in the world right now—Darfur is not the only place. There are active tyrants far worse than Saddam Hussein. Israel and Palestine are not the only neighbors in bloody conflict. America is a city on a hill, a lamp shining out to the world, but what kind of message does its beacon send? What does it stand for? Does it influence people by its goodness to stop their violence, hatred and greed? Does it respond to the wrongs of the world and the wrongs done against it with humble love? Does America live up to the ideals of the Sermon on the Mount and the earliest church? Does America sacrifice its self- interest and serve other nations in their time of need in the ways that Jesus did— healing the sick, feeding the poor and standing up boldly but nonviolently to injustice?

These are questions to ask yourself when you drive by the flags in Thetford Center. And if you have to answer no, America is not living up to its own ideals, do not despair. Remember that, “With God is great power to redeem.” God will redeem America from all its iniquities.

It is not too late. If one person or one neighborhood or one church can live up to these ideals, God’s power will flow through them to influence many others. “Have peace in yourself and thousands will find salvation around you.” (St. Seraphim of Sarov) Let the light of your good works shine, build a city on a hill here, and one day that light may grow to tip the balance and change the world. One day America may be the city built on a hill, the model of the realm of God that its founders envisioned. The power of that goodness and humble love would be greater than all our bombs. Have peace and justice and a spirit of charitable lovingkindness in America, and the world will find salvation around us—in Darfur, in Iraq, in Israel and Palestine, and in all the places like them. Let us pray in silence that these things shall be…


return to the top of page

return to Past Sermons Archive